Dispute #395

Court Start Date Dispute Status Current Period Time remaining End Date
Non-Technical 2020-09-23 10:59 Already Ruled Execution Already Ruled 2020-10-02 11:21
Arbitrable Creator

Unique Votes in all the rounds

Yes No Refuse to arbitrate Pending
0 2 0 1

Round 0

Yes No Refuse to arbitrate Pending
0 2 0 1
Round 0 Vote Casting Date
No 2020-09-28 03:41
No 2020-09-25 11:10


Evidences provided by Vagarish

Evidence #1:

Contradictory The challenger was so worried that the logo can cause asymmetry in the T2CR list and when shown how it aligns with the acceptable ones, still refuses to acknowledge it.

Evidence #2:

Not fair Actually this lines doesn't mean anything. Main question is "Is this icon at the center?" and this question's answer is NO. If you don't believe me please download and try to crop this icon. You will see answer by yourself then. Btw you should be careful and double check your submissions before submit them.

Evidence #3:

Properly aligned The logo is aligned with the rest and its full logo is shown - nothing was cut. See attached. This is a clear case of acceptable submission

Evidence #4:

Rules Rules are simple and you should read every single rules before submitting your entry. Everything is ok as you said instead of centering the icon. ➤ It should be centered and take most of the space available in the image. Rules are not looking for satisfaction. Noone wants to see asymmetric icons on Kleros T2CR list. When this submission accepted we can see an asymmetric Kleros T2CR list. So this submission should be refused.

Evidence #5:

Satisfactory The logo took the most space available, in high resolution, satisfied the pixel requirement and the size. The challenge on centering is only a major issue if a portion of it was cut. The transparent background makes the reason to reject quite minuscule.

Evidence #6:

Evidence Here is the attachment document. Also you can check by yourself. Download this icon and try to crop then you will see same screen. This submission should be refused.

Evidence #7:

Token challenge ➤The token symbol should be a transparent PNG of at least 128x128px and at most 2500x2500px. It should not weight more than 1MB. It should be centered and take most of the space available in the image. It should not include the project or token name unless the symbol always includes it. It should be of a definition high enough such that it should not appear pixelated or blurry unless those are on-purpose features of the symbol. Icon is not at the center.
Check this Case on Kleros Resolve