Evidence #16:
Clear violation of jurisprudence
Requester: "The guidelines are clear"
Response: It seems they are not clear for you, though. The transparent background rule only exists to eliminate submissions where the most commonly used logo consists of a transparent background, but where the requester provided a logo with a white background. In the case of logos where a non-transparent background is a feature, logos submitted to the TCR should also have that background. If that background is made transparent, it will violate the following policy rule: ➤The logo should be fully included. There was even a case where a submission was rejected, because the background of submitted logo was transparent, while the most commonly used logo had a white background (see STAKE dispute). The following tokens in the TCR all have a non transparent background: Fetch, Fantom, Crypto.com, Dock, SingularityNET, Maecenas, Swarm City, Swerve, SushiSwap, UniLayer, Unit Protocol, XIO, and STAKE. This evidence invalidates the argument of the requester, that all logos in the TCR must have a transparent background. The CAP dispute is one of the many disputes which set a precedent, that the most commonly used logo should be used, and no other. (https://tokens.kleros.io/token/0x329b51ee991166bf25ec4d66316c198ba91c431faaa039e0247795dd8e40a2be)
Requester: "Most media and professional sites will use this."
Response: Then why all of the media and professional sites consistently use the logo WITH the mint green background?
Requester: "The official tiny edges make the symbol look shiny which could be "features of the symbol.""
Response: Are you serious? It's just the effect of poorly cutting from a green background, making it low quality.
In summary, a precedent of using the most commonly used logo has been set numerous times. Thus, the only correct logo for Keep Network (KEEP) is the logo with a mint green background, as it's being used everywhere. I want to remind the jurors that guidelines are never 100% complete, this is impossible. Evidently, jurisprudence clearly shows that the most commonly used logo should be used, even if it consists of a colored background. Submitted logo obviously does not match the most commonly used logo and should therefore be rejected from the TCR.