Dispute #262

Court Start Date Dispute Status Current Period Time remaining End Date
Curation 2020-07-12 01:40 Already Ruled Execution Already Ruled 2020-08-04 20:47
Arbitrable Creator
Curate

Unique Votes in all the rounds

Yes No Refuse to arbitrate Pending
1 13 0 1

Round 0

Yes No Refuse to arbitrate Pending
1 2 0 0
Round 0 Vote Casting Date
Yes 2020-07-18 02:12
No 2020-07-15 20:03
No 2020-07-15 20:03

Round 1

Yes No Refuse to arbitrate Pending
0 7 0 0
Round 1 Vote Casting Date
No 2020-07-21 16:39
No 2020-07-22 18:33
No 2020-07-23 07:48
No 2020-07-21 16:52
No 2020-07-21 20:13
No 2020-07-22 03:59
No 2020-07-21 17:05

Round 2

Yes No Refuse to arbitrate Pending
1 13 0 1
Round 2 Vote Casting Date
No 2020-07-24 17:13
Yes 2020-07-25 03:20
No 2020-07-30 15:26
No 2020-07-25 23:02
No 2020-07-26 21:34
No 2020-07-26 21:34
No 2020-07-25 12:04
No 2020-07-26 01:05
No 2020-07-26 01:05
No 2020-07-26 01:05
No 2020-07-24 16:26
No 2020-07-25 19:37
No 2020-07-25 19:37
No 2020-07-24 15:49
Pending

Evidences

Evidences provided by Vagarish

Evidence #1:

Facts and upholding rules One cannot dismiss listing rules because submitter had clearly not carefully read them before making his submission. Using CCTIP is against rules. It was submitter's responsibility to submit his meme according to listing criteria. Jurors have to assess cases upon facts and rules, and not upon speculation of what were submitter's potential intentions. Otherwise, we would lose equity. So again, submitter should push a fresh submission of his meme while respecting rules. Meanwhile, this submission should be refused.

Evidence #2:

Fake Interactions If memes need no interactions to qualify why did you paid for fake interactions? Rules are really simple and submitter used @cctip_io for fake interactions.

Evidence #3:

Challenge Rebuttal The submission is the meme. The tweet is the medium to share the meme. We do not apply the 'fake interaction' criterion on the medium. Fake interactions only apply for submissions that uses 'interactions' as a metric to qualify. Memes need no interactions to qualify. This is clearly the intent of the policy.

Evidence #4:

Reviewing facts One has to carefully read list rules before submitting anything. By using CCTIP, submitter blatantly ignored/missed the rule that explicitly says that you cannot buy/use fake interactions. If submitter wanted to propose a meme only, I encourage him to do so by following the criteria and by doing a fresh submission with a sole link to the Meme. Meanwhile, this submission should be refused.

Evidence #5:

Who cares if some interactions are suspicious because the meme condition is met There is no point in rejecting a meme by looking into interactions, although they might be suspicious, when the meme is eligible *alone*. See, this submission title is about a "Meme", which is hosted here: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EclPUIpWAAMPpoy?format=jpg&name=large The restriction on fake interactions makes sense if there is a condition on minimum interactions. In those cases, as long as the minimum of interactions (in this case 0 for a meme, not 5 for any other image) is not mainly fake, it should be enough for acceptance. Any post can be subject to suspicious interactions or attacks for rejection (third-party interference was reported in the Kleros juror chat). Cctip was used in good faith, based on a DeversiFi's positive thought of it (screenshot submitted before), and it would be unfair to reject the meme altogether, or even reject there were at least 50 authentic views (stats submitted before) by just assuming they are mainly fake. This submission should be added.

Evidence #6:

mainly fake interactions mainly fake interactions Watch retweets Many bots without subscribers or just a few https://twitter.com/cryptoselfmemes/status/1281643163246112771/retweets

Evidence #7:

Memes require no interactions and the interactions are mainly unpaid Dear Jurors: 1) “Accept submissions that: … Are memes related to DeversiFi or its ecosystem.” Memes alone without a requirement on interactions are eligible. They have a long life of impact because of replication. 2) Although not necessary, only 5 retweets were rewarded with DOGE out of fun and for initial diffusion. The meme has more than the double of 5 RTs, so it would not be “mainly fake interactions”. By the way, Ben at DeversiFi has said “I think cctip.io is fine”: https://ibb.co/fGM3spV 3) The meme was printed way more than 50 times, so it may qualify under that condition too. Such impressed: https://ibb.co/qsK8pjj Submitted much respectfully.

Evidence #8:

Challenge Justification Submissions shouldn't be made of mainly fake interactions. ex: "Reject: The submitter paid for views of its YouTube video." The tweet uses @cctip_io service, which distributes reward to users that interact with the tweet, which is akin to paid interactions.
Check this Case on Kleros Resolve