Dispute #254

Court Start Date Dispute Status Current Period Time remaining End Date
Non-Technical 2020-07-11 15:37 Already Ruled Execution Already Ruled 2020-07-20 15:53
Arbitrable Creator

Unique Votes in all the rounds

Yes No Refuse to arbitrate Pending
1 1 0 1

Round 0

Yes No Refuse to arbitrate Pending
1 1 0 1
Round 0 Vote Casting Date
Yes 2020-07-14 15:52
No 2020-07-16 17:51


Evidences provided by Vagarish

Evidence #1:

Submission should be denied As this submission does not comply with the listing policies, jurors should vote NO in the appeal (see attachment for evidence).

Evidence #2:

No conditions are satisfied Policy: "Expand significantly the DeversiFi / Nectar knowledge base". Submitted Twitter thread does not significantly expand the existing knowledge base, thus does not satisfy above mentioned condition. Furthermore this submission also doesn't satisfy any of the other conditions, and should therefore be denied from the DeversiFi High Impact list.

Evidence #3:

3rd party opinion The "Is widely shared across social networks" condition is clear. There is an explicit example on how many shares it need to qualify: "Accept: An article, meme or tweet which is shared by at least 50 users." If a submission is to be accepted despite the low number of shares, it must satisfy any other conditions, ex: " Expand significantly the DeversiFi /Nectar knowledge base (explaining the trading process, how Nectar benefits DeversiFi traders, its use cases, other useful content, the flow and structure of dapps that integrate DeversiFi or Nectar, etc)"

Evidence #4:

lolĀ² https://curate.kleros.io/tcr/0x6f15Ca438992d9a4d7281E7E80381C4d904B2A24/0x7af7c72ecdd1fc4b143863d7a6cdb57517ea68035a8e1f28ffa1c9a82edd6db3 Amazing submission, literally copy pasting the website and accepted, much wow, are the views real ? i doubt so, 0.83cent over 1k views sounds fake. https://bidl.io/if-defi-is-2020s-defining-trend-deversifi-is-its-dex/ How is the audience quantified there ? Should i just post my thread on a random website ? :D https://curate.kleros.io/tcr/0x6f15Ca438992d9a4d7281E7E80381C4d904B2A24/0x7747a30178042286a36f0d915c2573d37d9157fcb1d7f14b6b5bc92f1c8f4ea6 Another website copy pasta, but in russian much wow 0 audience, was accepted right away At this point, please cancel my submission, i do not want to participate in this. Best of luck

Evidence #5:

what the f lol Should i buy retweets or likes like some other submissions ? It is pretty obvious when a 200 followers account have 100+ RT and likes, that simply bought. Here is an organic and real audience, unlike most of the submissions here. The same as some of the submissions for the this tier have less interactions than this tweet but were accepted If that's how the submissions are being treated, i'm not so sure now about what i just wrote on NEC

Evidence #6:

Challenge Justification Submission does not comply with the high impact policies and should be denied. I advise the submitter to submit this to the standard impact list. "Is widely shared across social networks." - At the moment the thread has 2 retweets and 7 likes.
Check this Case on Kleros Resolve